“Okay, fine.” That’s how Trouble In Dreams begins.
“Okay, fine.” A far cry from the “revolution, revolution, revolution” that launched Destroyer. Kind of resigned, actually. And resignation’s a theme throughout Trouble In Dreams.
“Nah, it’s cool.” “The state cut off my arms.” “Foam hands.” “Now it’s gone, and the whole point of everything’s the moving on.” “We live in darkness. The light is a dream.” “Common scars brought us together.” “Hands tied behind your head.” “The leopard of honor speaks to a crowd of the dead.” “I was stuck inside a river’s flow.” “You’ve been wandering around, you’ve been fucking around.” In every song, there are conciliatory lyrics, helpless feelings, acceptance of reality. It’s not that reality is accepted because it’s okay, but because there’s nothing else to accept.
The music on Trouble In Dreams fits somewhere between the free-spirited ease of This Night and the professional rock of Rubies. It’s unapologetically pretty. The singing–bearing in mind that Bejar’s vocals are a matter of taste–is even kind of pretty. In a sense, the revolution is over. The status quo hasn’t changed, the temple has not fallen, but Dan Bejar seems more comfortable in himself than ever. That doesn’t mean complacency; Bejar is still making great music.
“My Favorite Year” captures what I mean. It’s a beautiful song, and its lyrics wistfully blend acceptance with anger…
You, in white, and me, in gray, go well tonight,
so let’s linger here,
this used to be my favorite palm tree–
I was starving in that shit-house, the world–
but now it’s gone,
and the whole point of everything’s the moving on.
[…]
It was a very good year.
And now it’s gone.
You say the whole point of everything’s the moving on,
and I can’t help but feel somewhat opposed to this,
my shit having been torched by fascists,
though, in some small way, we’re all traitors to our own kind.

[…] theme of the last Destroyer full-length, Trouble In Dreams, at least as I understood it, was one of resignation. I’d previously read the rest of discography as rock ‘n roll […]