For lovers of irony, I submit Joanna Newsom’s 2010 album, Have One On Me. The first song is called “Easy,” and Ms. Newsom sings the title, invitingly, a couple times. Those familiar with Ms. Newsom’s work would probably not use that word with regard to her music. Her 2006 album, Ys is a modern chamber folk classic, heavy on the harp, consisting of only five songs, but clocking in just short of an hour. The songs on her 2004 debut, The Milk-Eyed Mender are more accessible in length and style, but Ms. Newsom’s voice — which has been compared unfavorably, albeit fairly, to that of Sandy Cheeks, the squirrel friend of SpongeBob SquarePants — can be jarring (personally, I love it, but I understand how it can be off-putting). And so, after only a few seconds of “Easy,” the word suddenly makes sense. Ms. Newsom’s voice is more reminiscent of Joni Mitchell than Sandy Cheeks, and the music is warm and evocative.
Then, the song goes on for six minutes. Then, the album goes on for two hours. It’s a triple LP. It’s 18 songs long. It’s almost as if Ms. Newsom is trying to maintain some distance by refusing to allow her music to be experienced easily. Her first two albums demanded an open mind. Have One On Me demands an open schedule. Personally, I’m not a fan of double LPs, and I think many of them could be considerably better if they were whittled down to the length of an LP. A triple LP is something else, entirely. I don’t even have a frame of reference for something like this. And, still, it’s easily one of my favorite albums of the year.
The ease of Have One On Me may be embedded into its unwieldy length. I love to put on my headphones and pay close attention to an album, but that’s not really something I can do with Have One On Me. Instead, I put it on and read a book or do some things around the house. I have listened to it on a couple of flights, and its dulcet tones make it a perfect choice for airplanes. Basically, I go about my life at its most mundane while listening. The melodies and the lyrics sort of drift like a fragrance on a breeze, which — I don’t know — seems to be by design.
I’m thinking about how life is mostly mundane, even if our memories are dominated by the less-mundane moments. Love at first sight lasts a moment, and then love becomes a matter of daily-ness. The sinner has the conversion experience, and then the believer pursues a life of discipleship. There is beauty in the mundane that may not be all that fashionable right now. Even with a slagging economy, our access to anything we want is less fettered than ever. I confess that this culture of access has done little to strengthen my patience. I’ve often felt like Homer Simpson at the Bachman-Turner Overdrive concert: “Get to the ‘working overtime’ part!”
Have One On Me is music that redeems the mundane. Rest assured, it is replete with proverbial “working overtime” parts. Sprinkled throughout the sprawling 124 minutes are some of the most haunting melodies, some of the prettiest sounds, and some of the most compelling lyrics of music in recent memory. For example, there are thirty seconds in the middle of “Easy” that I can’t hear enough…
…Hear the frog going courtin’
till the day he croaks.
Saying even then,
how there is light in the river,
and there’s a river made of light.
C’mon, you little life-giver,
give your life.
This section starts out with minimal piano tinkling that builds and is soon accompanied by a flute, and then an orchestra. I love everything about those thirty seconds. In my estimation, they are perfect. Other moments are like that. Granted, none are as succinctly distilled as “working overtime,” but they are perfect in their own ways. On the title track, Ms. Newsom rhymes “King of Bavaria” with “can I see ya,” and I smile reflexively every time I hear it. In each of the 18 songs, there seems to be something, however subtle, that feels like magic, if for only a second. The aforementioned redemption of the mundane occurs in the spaces between. The less thrilling moments of Have One On Me are nevertheless stunning; it is all written, performed, and produced impeccably.
This album may very well be a kind of antidote to that thing within me that has me cursing the 15-second advertisements on Hulu and looking repeatedly at my watch while waiting for an elevator. Upon every listen, my admiration for Have One On Me seems to be stretched, sometimes by only a few seconds, and other times by several minutes. Joanna Newsom did not make Have One On Me easy to consume, but she did make it nearly impossible to turn off.
Lex! Another good album and another good post! I can’t comment fast enough to keep up, but I really love this personal review style you’ve been developing. You’re on a roll!
Thanks, Katy! I appreciate it.