I wasn’t quite sure what to make of Nitsuh Abebe’s latest column for Pitchfork, “How to Be a Vampire.” In it, he turns the nostalgia talking point on its head, and reminisces over his approach to music in adolescence, “listening like a vampire, listening because I desired to suck something out of the music for my own purposes.” He considers music’s role in the youthful search for identity. That’s something with which I can relate, but just as soon as I think Mr. Abebe is holding up a mirror, I see all the letters backwards. He writes in italics, “I led myself to like the Cramps because I wanted to try being the sort of person who liked the Cramps.” My experience was opposite that; for example, I led myself to being the sort of person who wore work boots, thrifted Wranglers, and pearl snaps because I fell in love with Uncle Tupelo’s family tree.
Essentially, I read the column with a lot of eye scrunching and head tilting. I’m almost with him, especially on his emotionally persuasive conclusion, but not quite. It seems like he’s longing for a second-best feeling. It seems like he’s leaving out that moment when a song, an album, or a sound is so immediate, so absorbing, that the music, itself, is the only thing that matters. The best feeling for me is musical rapture, when I’m caught up just as I am. That happened when I was 13, and it’s still happening, two decades later.
Cymabls Eat Guitars’ debut album, Why There Are Mountains (audio: Spotify) is a good example. In 2009, it was a semi-early indicator of ‘90s revivalism. It’s a throwback to “indie rock” (as opposed to “indie”) with obvious influences, and possibly the first “nostalgia” piece that points to and draws from something I actually lived through with conscious awareness. Maybe it’s my own fond familiarity for “this kind of music” that created a delay in recognizing what was going on, but I didn’t even think about Why There Are Mountains in terms of “revivalism” and “nostalgia” until I read the reviews and blogs.
I never had a chance to think about fashion and lifestyle trends. Even listening now, within the first second, I’m enthralled completely. All it takes is that blast of guitars, drums, bass, and the cry, “Whoa-oh, oh-oh, oh-oh, oh-oh, oh! Whoa-oh, ho, oh, ah-ah,” and I’m in a different space. The album screams and whispers, stops and starts, and my body follows suit. My head nods or bangs in time with the beat and in agreement with lyrics that mostly become glossolalia, anyway. During the 45 minutes of Why There Are Mountains, I have no thoughts of getting something from the music beyond what it offers on its own terms, nor of any pop-cultural trends and their sociological implications. I’m all reflexes, all movement, and my headphones can’t turn up loud enough. Everything is visceral and mystical until the music stops and my ears are left ringing. I’m left wanting nothing.
As you know, I love this album. I love this post, too. I especially like this line: “I led myself to being the sort of person who wore work boots, thrifted Wranglers, and pearl snaps because I fell in love with Uncle Tupelo’s family tree.” And that last paragraph is perfect.
Thanks, Katy!